Effectiveness of ‘Kanyahree Prakalpa’:
An Analytical Study based on Surveyed villages of West Bengal
Asish Kumar Pal
Assistant Professor, Economics Department, Tarakeswar Degree College,
Tarakeswar, Hooghly, West Bengal, India.
*Corresponding Author E-mail: asish.kr.pal@gmail.com
ABSTRACT:
The Government of West Bengal, Honourable Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee has announced an innovative scheme named “Kanyashree Prakalpa” under the Department of Women Development of Social Welfare in August 2013. This scheme is a conditional direct cash transfer scheme for young girls between the ages of 13 and 18. Many impoverished parents of under developed countries find no economic rationale in investing to girl’s education and marry them to enhance the family security. This paper attempts to show a design to reduce drop out, prevent forced child marriage and motivate to attain higher education and well health of the girls.
INTRODUCTION:
“Mago tomaibolchisonobiyeakhonkorbona
Lekhaporaswapnaamarbhanga kore diona
Vidyalyermastermosaibollesedin
Amar porar Khorachjatailagukkanyshreedai
Bhavcho kano tumimago kanya ratnaami
Sujogpelebujhiedebo kanya kotodami
Kanyshreebarchheakhonsabarghoreghore
Ami hobo Kanyshreelekhapora kore
Biyer kotha bolo na ma amar kotha sono
Lekhaporakharap to noitumio ta jano
Tabu kano dhwangsakorbeamarlekhapora
Sabuj baganjaliediledekhbekamonkshara”
(Collected)
Kanyashree being a famous scheme of Government of West Bengal has received International recognition. Department for International Development, United Kingdom and UNISEF have selected this project for presentation at the “Girl Summit” 2014 to be held in London (Source: www.unisef.org, July 22, 2014).
The Government of West Bengal has taken a special initiative for Girl child education in 2012 and in this respect, under the supervision of theDepartment of Women Development and Social Welfare (DWSW). Thestate has introduced a scheme called “Kannyashree Prakalpa” in October 2013 for addressing two major challenges in the society a girl’sdropout from school and the prevalence of a girl child marriage (Source: Kanyashree Prakalpa Guideleine-2013). It seeks to improve the status and well-being of girls, especially those from socio-economically disadvantagesfamilies through Conditional Cash Transfer. It is applicable to the State of West Bengal only. The scheme has two benefit components. Firstly, a cash benefit to be paid annually to the girls in the target age group for every year that they remained in education, provided they were unmarried at the time. The second benefit is a one-time grant, to be paid when a girl turned 18, provided that she was still engaged in an academic or occupational pursuit and was unmarried onher18th birthday (Available at https//www.kanyashree.gov.in).
The scheme was highly praised by ‘UNISEF’ that provides technical ass is tance to the scheme and is aiding the state in its evaluation and monitoring processes (Source: www.unisef.org, July 22, 2014). It was also awarded by the United Nationsin the Netherland sin July 2017 (https//un.wikipedia.org). So, the scheme is recognised by both national and international platform. No doubt there is an opportunity to ventilate the options of the students, teachers and parents regarding the effectiveness of Prakalpa. However, following the basic issues of girls’ students the paper tries to examine the effectiveness of this scheme helping the poor girl children to pursue education, preventing drop out and reducing child marriage that may prevent from early pregnancies, malnutrition among children, poverty etc.
In an interesting paper written by (Sen and Dutta Vol. 53, Issue No. 17, 28 Apr, 2018) published in this journal, and assessment of KP is made. The sampled in two districts only Murshidabad and Cooch Behar in West Bengal. These districts are deemed to be backward districts by yardstick of development. The authors find significant relationship between KP and the drop in parameter, dropout and underage marriage. This has been confirmed by a Cohorts study. They also try to find out the utilization of fund. This also seemed in the favour of the women.
This study has covered wide geographical area but with very limited cope. Assessing KP could not be done properly within such a limited umbrella. Firstly, the effects on dropout and underage married depend on a complexity of factor i.e. difficult to ascertain so easy. It would require a more rigorous analysis where first essay can be single out from other possible effects. Secondly, it is not even necessary. The aim of KP is to generate a more conclusive atmosphere for female learning. This involves not only in transfer of funds but
also the formation of KP student groups consisting of girl students in the school. These groups play an active role in motivating people toward woman education also their own self esteem in developed. The effects of all these can be brought out in a more inconclusive study of a particular area. We hope to do this in the present paper.
Many analyses wrongly compare KP with programmed of money transfer to the girl students. But KP is broader than these. Under KP and active KP coordination in form between girl students, parents, schools, local authorities both civil and police in each school KP group of students is formed. Under the tutelage of teachers these groups have many activities. Their primary aim is to prevent under age marriage. Whenever they get any news of such a marriage is going to be arranged. They try to prevent it taking the help of their teachers and local authorities. They also counsel the child and her parents whose marriage was been arranged. They also take part in various cultural activities. It also involves inter school KP group competition. The victors are applauded for their social service. All these instill a sense of the dignity and awareness among girls. These effects are far beyond a transfer of funds.
Surveying method and Collection of data:
The paper is based mainly on primary data, collected information relating to Kannyashree scheme in west Bengal from Kannyashree beneficiaries of selected panchayets of Arambagh block area in Hooghly district. 100 adolescent girls (Enrolled in school and college) were taken randomly as population to collect data from the study area. The interview method of survey was purposive which subjective as well as objective. The ultimate objective of study is to understand the importance of ‘Kanyashree scholarship’ on school going girls.This surveyed article may have highly sociological, economical and educational significance.
Socio-Economic Framework:
The analysis is carried out in this paper is descriptive. The socio-economic framework of the girls’ students has been explained by analysing various social and economical characteristics. Now we enter into various collected information one by one.
About 45% of our sample girls are between 13-15 years of age while 37% are in the 16-18 age groups. However, 18% is above 18 years (in table 1). Here age is considered as one of the parameters because age is vital for availing this scheme. The another parameter (in table 2) is shown by the enrollment in class Standard it is evident from the table 2that 42% are in class VIII - X. 38% of the responded is in class X - XII, And 20% sample is taken from the girl students who are more than class XI. Enrollment is very necessary criteria to register for achieving of Kanyashree Prakalpa. It is also observed that most of the beneficiaries have been started receiving the benefits from class VIII. The enrollment of schooling of the different caste categories reveals (Table 3) that scheduled castes are more compared to other categories. Out of total 100 girls constitute 37, 12 scheduled tribes, 25 other back ward classes (Including Minority girls) and 26 from general category. This reflects that scholarship of this scheme is highly occupied from the backward society.
Table 1: Distribution of students by age group
|
Age |
No of respondent girl students |
Rich |
Poor |
|
13-15 |
45 |
22 |
23 |
|
16-18 |
37 |
18 |
19 |
|
Greater than 18 |
18 |
12 |
06 |
(Source: Field Survey)
Table 2: Enrolment in the standard of education
|
Class standard of Schooling |
No of respondent girl students |
Rich |
Poor |
|
VIII-X |
42 |
20 |
22 |
|
XI-XII |
38 |
18 |
20 |
|
More than XII |
20 |
12 |
08 |
(Source: Field Survey)
Table 3: Distribution of students by caste category
|
Category of Caste |
No of respondent girl students |
Rich |
Poor |
|
General |
26 |
14 |
12 |
|
SC |
37 |
12 |
25 |
|
ST |
12 |
03 |
09 |
|
OBC (Including Minority) |
25 |
11 |
14 |
(Source: Field Survey)
Our next consideration is parent’s educational background which indicates the familiar educational status in the society. A majority of their parents is primary (46%) educated. Only a few (14%) has been qualified either higher secondary and above (Table 4). It can be said that the beneficiaries are first learner generations in this study. It is very interesting point to be noted that a large number (44%) of their parents are daily labour. 23% belongs to agriculture sector. 15% and 18% are doing small and micro business and private job. From the table 6, the income category of parents is less than Rs. 30,000/- per annum and there are a number of respondents from poor background whose income fall between Rs. 30,001/- to 50,000/- per annum. (Data is authenticated by Gram Panchayet for the said income group). It shows that only 20% respondents earn more than Rs. 50,000/- per annum. Table 7 shows the pattern of land holding of their families. A large portion (68%) of their families have only house for shelter and a small proportion (32%) has both house and homestead for agriculture. Here almost all the poor and middle-income group families have built up the house under the scheme of “Bangla Abas Yona” (Formerly PMAY).
Table 4: Distribution of students according to parent’s educational background
|
Education of Parents |
No of respondents |
Rich |
Poor |
|
Illiterate |
07 |
00 |
07 |
|
Primary |
46 |
11 |
35 |
|
Secondary |
33 |
20 |
13 |
|
Higher Secondary and above |
14 |
10 |
04 |
(Source: Field Survey)
Table 5: Occupation of parents
|
Occupation |
No of respondents |
Rich |
Poor |
|
Daily labour |
44 |
17 |
27 |
|
Pretty business |
15 |
09 |
06 |
|
Agriculture |
23 |
15 |
08 |
|
Private sector |
18 |
11 |
07 |
(Source: Field Survey)
Table 6: Parent’s income level
|
Income Annual |
No of respondents |
Rich |
Poor |
|
Upto 30,000 |
35 |
14 |
21 |
|
30,001- 50,000 |
55 |
30 |
25 |
|
Above 50,000 |
20 |
13 |
07 |
(Source: Field Survey)
Table 7: Distribution of students according to land holding pattern of family
|
Land holding of family |
No of respondents |
Rich |
Poor |
|
Only house |
68 |
22 |
46 |
|
Homestead land and house |
32 |
20 |
12 |
(Source: Field Survey)
In table 8 from the other status of the family from the different institutions like PRI, Co-operative Society, NGO and School Committees we see only 03% parents are engaged in school committees.
Table 8: Other status of the family
|
Status of Parents |
No of respondent girl students |
Rich |
Poor |
|
Member in PRIs |
00 |
00 |
00 |
|
Member in Co-operative Society |
15 |
11 |
04 |
|
Member in NGOs |
00 |
00 |
00 |
|
Member in School Committees |
03 |
02 |
01 |
(Source: Field Survey)
The survey consisted of some subjective questions relating to benefit or favour of this scheme from the respondent students herself and some in form of view or opinion of their parents and school authorities and teachers.
Now from the view points of students it is seen (in table 9) that the maximum respondents (64%) invest the money from “Kanyashree Project” in their study like buying books, invest in project, given tuition fees etc. 22% has responded that they have deposited the fund into bank. Only a mere (14%) has spent to other purposes likebuy dress, cosmetics, buy domestic instruments etc. Table 10 shows (95%) respondents have admitted positively assistance from this scheme. From the table 11, 95% students clearly want to continue this programme for its various benefits. Table 2 indicates that only 08% of students do not get theirmoneyontime due to error in bank account and other mistake but 92% of students have mentioned that they have not face dany problem sinthis project.Similarly From the table 13itisseen that 92% of students have received help in their study from this project So it is clear that Kanyasree helps the girl’s students in their study.
Type of Utilisation |
No of sample girls |
Rich |
Poor |
BankDeposit |
22 |
07 |
15 |
Investinstudy |
64 |
34 |
30 |
Otherpurpose |
14 |
04 |
10 |
(Source: Field Survey)
Any form of help or assistance |
No of sample girls |
Rich |
Poor |
Positive response |
95 |
48 |
47 |
Negative response |
01 |
01 |
00 |
Cannot say |
04 |
01 |
03 |
(Source: Field Survey)
Continuation of this programme |
No of respondents |
Rich |
Poor |
Favour |
95 |
42 |
53 |
Not in favour |
00 |
00 |
00 |
Cannot say |
05 |
02 |
03 |
(Source: Field Survey)
Various problems faced |
No of respondents |
Rich |
Poor |
Error in account |
05 |
01 |
04 |
Not get money on time |
03 |
02 |
01 |
No problem |
92 |
48 |
44 |
(Source: Field Survey)
Assistance for study |
No of respondents |
Rich |
Poor |
Help to study |
91 |
47 |
45 |
Not help to study |
03 |
02 |
01 |
Cannot say |
06 |
01 |
05 |
(Source: Field Survey)
Then coming to the consideration of opinionof school teachers and authority in table 14, almost all the girl respondent students (Near about 90%) agreed that their teachers and school authorities support the scheme, have not faced any problem and admitted help in improvement of students enrollment in education and help to decrease in drop out of students from education.
The last table 15 reflects the parents’ views or opinions from the various parameters. Similarly, almost all the girl students (Near about 90%) have agreed that that their parents have not denied ‘Kanyshree Prakalpa’ helps to decline the forced girl marriage, assists to reduce mortality rate of immature mothers, even encourages to send their daughters in school and to stay in education field.
Table 14: View of teachers and school authorities on ‘Kanyashree scheme’
|
Advantages and benefits of Kanyashree Prakala |
Yes |
No |
Cannot say |
|||||||
|
Total |
Rich |
Poor |
Total |
Rich |
Poor |
Total |
Rich |
Poor |
||
|
Support by teachers and school authorites for helping in study |
97 |
41 |
46 |
01 |
00 |
01 |
02 |
00 |
02 |
|
|
Help in improvement of students enrollment |
99 |
45 |
47 |
01 |
01 |
00 |
00 |
00 |
00 |
|
|
Help to decrease in drop out of students from education |
89 |
46 |
43 |
06 |
02 |
04 |
05 |
03 |
02 |
|
|
Any problems faced y school in this scheme |
06 |
01 |
05 |
90 |
40 |
50 |
04 |
01 |
03 |
|
(Source: Field Survey)
Table 15: Parents View on several favours of ‘Kanyashree scheme’ on behalf of students
|
Opinion about encouragement |
Yes |
No |
Cannot say |
||||||
|
Total |
Rich |
Poor |
Total |
Rich |
Poor |
Total |
Rich |
Poor |
|
|
Help in delaying of early girls marriage |
92 |
41 |
51 |
05 |
01 |
04 |
03 |
02 |
01 |
|
Help in reduction of mortality of immature mother |
89 |
45 |
44 |
06 |
02 |
04 |
05 |
01 |
04 |
|
Programme encourages to send daugh terin school |
85 |
45 |
40 |
05 |
03 |
02 |
10 |
03 |
07 |
|
Encourage student for the study |
90 |
45 |
45 |
02 |
00 |
02 |
08 |
05 |
03 |
(Source: Field Survey)
CONCLUSION:
From the above discussion the paper reaches in conclusion that ‘Kanyashree’ scheme has several positive benefits for girls’ students especially from backward society. It helps the economically weak students and their families. Parents are alsoencouraged by this Prakalpa to involve their girl child 13-18 years in schooling system of education field. Due to lack of money, their parents wanted to get married them as these girls are burden to them. As a result of introduction of this scheme it is one type of blessings on them. It is very clear to all this programme helps girl students by several ways like in improvement of study of students, delaying Girls child marriage, reduce immature mothers mortality rate, improvement of interest of learner in study etc . Even the school teachers have admitted that it helps to decrease drop out the girl students in education. This study reflects that if the Government takes these innovative and initiates programmes more and more than a lot of girls will be benefited. So at last we can say studying these sample girls who can cover the whole Bengal that ‘Kanyashree scheme’ scholarship is appreciable to government of West Bengal in spite of some drawbacks.
REFERENCE:
1. Adhikari, K (2017). The Role of Kanyashree PrakalpaIn Empowering Adolescent Girlsin WestBengal, International Research Journal of Management and Commerce, Associated Asia Research Foundation, vol-4, p305-315
2. Baseline Survey for Socio-Economic Indicator Sin West Bengal-2014, Available at https/www.wbkanyashree.gov.in/
3. Bhattacharya, D. (2017). Impact of Kanyashree Prakalpa On Educational Progress of School Going Girls in Burdwan District: A CaseStudy, Available at https// Department of Women Development and Social Welf are (2014) Rapid Assessment kanya Shreeprakalpa, 2015, Available at https// www.wbkanyashree.gov.in
4. Sen Dutta (2018), West Bengal's Successful Kanyashree Prakalpa Programme Needs More Push From Stateand Beneficiaries,“EPW”,Vol-53,IssueNo17,2018
5. Kanyashree Prakalpa: Implementation Guideline, Department of Women Development and Social Welfare, Government of West Bengal, August-2013, https//www.kanyashreeprakalpaguideline.gov.in
6. www.un.wikipedia.org
7. www.censusindia.gov.in/vitalstatistics/SRSReport
|
Received on 12.08.2024 Revised on 09.09.2024 Accepted on 01.10.2024 Published on 05.12.2024 Available online on December 31, 2024 Res. J. of Humanities and Social Sciences. 2024;15(4):287-291. DOI: 10.52711/2321-5828.2024.00044 ©AandV Publications All right reserved
|